Escape from Mr. Lemoncello’s Library: the Graphic Novel

Escape from Mr. Lemoncello’s Library: the Graphic NovelEscape from Mr. Lemoncello's Library: The Graphic Novel by Chris Grabenstein, Douglas Holgate
Published by Random House Graphic on November 7, 2023
ISBN: 0593484851
Pages: 249
Genres: Adventure
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
two-stars

A graphic novel adaptation of the wildly popular prose series. This book mostly follows the original storyline with direct text from the novel. For those kids who prefer and delight in a visualization of a story, this one may disappoint. Though the illustrations are rendered by Douglas Holgate of the Last Kids on Earth series, they are far too cartoonish for the depth, nuance, and detail that the original source material requires. Many of the illustrations are blown up, showing close-up faces; this was jarring and didn’t allow for the characters to move in the space of Lemoncello’s extraordinary library. And Luigi Lemoncello himself had no panache or dignity instead coming off as a cartoon character similar to the 70s PSA cartoon Timer who “hankered for a hunk o’ cheese.”  It never felt like the library was a character in the GN the way it did in the book.

Readers love graphic novels and if this edition draws in new readers who might not read a lengthy prose series, or if it inspires readers to check out the original Grabenstein books, then it is a success. But as a whole, it is a disappointing endeavor that does not enhance anything that readers of the original material might love.

Reviewed by Jill O’Connor, Falmouth Middle School

two-stars

Club Kick Out: Into the Ring

Club Kick Out: Into the RingClub Kick Out!: Into the Ring (Club Kick Out, 1) by Stephanie Mided
ISBN: 0063116464
Genres: Humor
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars

“Club Kick Out!: Into the Ring” is the first in a new series of graphic novels written and illustrated by Steph Mided. Sasha is nervous and excited to start seventh grade. She might even try to become the president of the gaming club! Unfortunately the new principal declares that there will be no more extracurricular clubs besides sports due to budget problems. After getting randomly placed into a group of students for an English class project, Sasha and her new friends end up trying to start a Pro Wrestling Club since it would count as a sport. Sasha and friends deal with bullying, anxiety, friendship troubles, and overparenting and come out as champs in the end. Bright and colorful illustrations and overall humor and kindness make this a fun and enjoyable read. Aimed at ages 8 to 12, this is a recommended purchase for any middle grade graphic novel collection.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

four-stars

The Magicians

The MagiciansThe Magicians by Blexbolex, Karin Snelson
Published by Enchanted Lion Books on November 7, 2023
ISBN: 1592704042
Pages: 210
Genres: Fairy Tale, Fantasy, Magical Realism
Format: Graphic Novel
Goodreads
five-stars

This stunner of a graphic novel is the story of three magicians who appear in a house after a mysterious absence and are immediately chased by a hunter and a mechanical lion, aka The Clinker. The magicians escape and scatter but are eventually rounded up after three separate adventures.

Blexbolex has created a visually arresting, captivating fairy tale that can easily be recommended to anyone. While it’s a terrific children’s book, the vintage story book style prints are beautiful enough to consider it an art book. It would be easy to get swept up in the images and ignore the text but that would be a mistake; the story is well written, witty, and magical, and uses phrases like “exasperating, long-reigning silence”, impudent companion”, and “thriving, exuberant mess”. The text is advanced, but the illustrations help explain the meanings of tougher words and will broaden vocabularies. A must have!

Reviewed by Sarah Maciejewski, Patten Free Library, Bath

 

five-stars

Lo & Behold

Lo & BeholdLo and Behold (Lo and Behold #1) by Wendy Mass, Gabi Mendez
Published by Random House Graphic on May 2, 2023
ISBN: 0593179633
Pages: 224
Genres: Realistic Fiction
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars

This middle grade graphic novel packs a lot into the plot. In the prologue, Addie is a happy kid with a mom and a dad, but then her mom has an accident which leads to her absence in Addie’s life. Mass is purposely vague about the whereabouts of Addie’s mom, has she died, is she in the hospital? Chapter one starts a year later, summer time, and Addie and her father, a futurist, are traveling across country so that he can work on a virtual reality project at a prestigious university. With a futurist for a father, Addie is familiar with tech toys and tools. Her father’s team is working on cutting edge projects to solve real-world problems or to help people, and they hope the projects will be funded by grants.

Addie meets gregarious, outgoing Mateo, who serves as a foil to her reserved nature. She is hesitant to let Mateo in to her thoughts and her life story, but as the book progresses, Addie learns that she is not alone in her sadness; even outgoing people can harbor painful pasts and family trauma. Mateo, and the kind college students, craft a virtual reality (VR) program for Addie based on her love of space, moon seeds & trees in particular (explained further in the author’s note), and Addie learns to let joy back into her life. The reader learns what has happened to Addie’s mom and there is a satisfying conclusion. The story is personal to Mass and is well-told. Those who have trouble with inference or following a more complicated plot may be a little confused with all of the threads, but they are neatly wrapped up if they stick with it. Give to fans of realistic fiction graphic novels in grades 5-8.

Reviewed by by Jill O’Connor, Falmouth Middle School

four-stars

The Terribles: Clash of the Gnomes!

The Terribles: Clash of the Gnomes!The Terribles #3: Clash of the Gnomes! by Travis Nichols
ISBN: 0593425790
Genres: Fantasy, Humor
Format: Chapter Book Fiction, Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
three-stars

“Clash of the Gnomes” is the third book in Travis Nichols’ “The Terribles” middle grade mixed prose/graphic novel series. On an island where monsters/aliens/cryptids can live in peace without humans trying to destroy them, Nichols follows the daily life of the children of the monsters. In this installment, each chapter follows a different story. The monster children are challenged to a game of creepoball by gnomes from a nearby island, the invisible boy and his friends form an “EXTREME” club, the band “Vlad and the Maggots” put on a show, and more!

The monsters show friendship, acceptance, and humor throughout the story. The book is a mixture of graphic novel style illustrations and prose, similar to the Diary of a Wimpy Kid series. Readers will enjoy the silly antics and the funny ways that the monsters go about their lives. Aimed at ages 8 to 12, this series is a good addition to collections where middle grade graphic novel/prose hybrid books are popular.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

three-stars

The Stupendous Switcheroo: New Powers Every 24 Hours

The Stupendous Switcheroo: New Powers Every 24 HoursThe Stupendous Switcheroo: New Powers Every 24 Hours by Chad Sell, Mary Winn Heider
ISBN: 0593427300
Genres: Science Fiction
Format: Chapter Book Fiction, Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
three-stars

The first book in “The Stupendous Switcheroo” series, “New Powers Every 24 Hours,” is a combination graphic and prose novel written by Mary Winn Heider and illustrated by Chad Sell. The book starts with our main character waking up with unexpected superpowers. Deciding to become a superhero, they call the headquarters of their favorite superhero, Vin Valor to see if he needs any super help. They do! The Stupendous Switcheroo learns that becoming a superhero isn’t easy, especially when your powers change every day.

Part adventure, part mystery, middle grade readers will enjoy the humor and excitement as well as the black, white, and teal illustrations throughout the book. Aimed at readers age 8 to 12, this book is a recommended purchase wherever mixed graphic/prose middle grade books (similar to “Diary of a Wimpy Kid”) are popular.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

three-stars

Drawn to Change the World

Drawn to Change the WorldDrawn to Change the World Graphic Novel Collection: 16 Youth Climate Activists, 16 Artists by Anoosha Syed, Bill Masuku, Derick Brooks, Devon Holzworth, Emma Reynolds, Erin Hunting, Gloria Felix, Jade Zhang, Margarita Kukhtina, Natasha Donovan, Natasha Nayo, Shivana Sookdeo, Teo Duvall
ISBN: 0063084228
Genres: Non-Fiction
Format: Graphic Novel, Nonfiction
Goodreads
four-stars

Drawn to Change the World pairs 16 youth climate activists with 16 illustrators to offer some hope for the future of our environment. These kids and teens are remarkable and are doing wondrous things to help save our planet.

Each chapter is set up as a brief biography of the activists with different illustrators contributing to the graphic novel format of the book. While it is a graphic novel, there is plenty of straight text as well, and the additional information is very extensive. It lists a lot ways to connect to other activists through social media, which allows for immediate action for youth who are interested.

Reviewed by Sarah Maciejewski, Patten Free Library, Bath

four-stars

Shark and Bot: Epic Roller Coaster Ride!

Shark and Bot: Epic Roller Coaster Ride!Shark and Bot #4: Epic Roller Coaster Ride!: (A Graphic Novel) by Brian Yanish
ISBN: 0593485378
Genres: Animals, Humor
Format: Graphic Novel
Goodreads
four-stars

“Epic Roller Coaster Ride” is the fourth book in the Shark and Bot graphic novel series by Brian Yanish. Best friends Shark (a shark) and Bot (a robot) are excited about going to a theme park and riding the roller coasters, but end up getting stuck bringing Bot’s little sister with them. Shark and Bot show how to be responsible and the importance of honesty (when Shark admits to Bot that he really doesn’t want to go on the biggest coaster and is afraid) in friendship.

The illustrations are funny and bright and add to the book’s humor. Aimed at kids ages five through eight, this is a suggested purchase for middle grade graphic novel collections in all libraries.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

four-stars

Shakti

ShaktiShakti by S.J. Sindu, Nabi H. Ali
Published by Harper Alley on May 23, 2023
ISBN: 0063090139
Pages: 248
Genres: Fantasy
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars

Shakti is a young Indian American girl who has moved around a bit. Now, rooted for a few years while her mom completes a phD, Shakti is hoping to make friends. When she meets Xi, things start looking up. However, her middle school has three mean girls named Harini, Emily, and Kelly (HEK) who seem to have the entire school under their sway.

Sindu’s world is one in which magic is accessible to many and is incorporated into the flow of life. Shakti is a descendant of the goddess Durga Ma and has access to ancient Indian magic. Durga Ma is a goddess of light and strength, but she is tied to her twin Kali Ma, the goddess of death and destruction. When one wields the power of Durga Ma care has to be taken not to also awaken Kali Ma. When Xi and Shakti attempt to stop a powerful spell being cast by HEK, they not only tap into Durga Ma’s power, but they bring forth Kali Ma, who proceeds to spread illness and destruction across the town, including to Shakti’s own mother who is about to have a baby.

Each page contains just a few panels and the illustrations are bright and dynamic. Readers will be drawn to the fiery title on the cover and to the topics of witchcraft and magic. The story is well-crafted with interludes to explain the two forces that are Durga Ma and Kali Ma. Readers will be drawn into the action and will route for Shakti as she races to undo her clumsy spell. A book that explores the challenges of growing up and being ready to handle things with real-world consequences. Highly recommend for any middle grade graphic novel collection.

Reviewed by Jill O’Connor, Falmouth Middle School

four-stars

Dear Rosie

Dear RosieDear Rosie by Meghan Boehman, Rachael Briner
Published by Alfred A. Knopf Books for Young Readers on July 11, 2023
ISBN: 059357186X
Pages: 208
Genres: Animals, Juvenile Fiction / Action & Adventure / General, Mental Health
Format: Graphic Novel
Goodreads
five-stars

Millie, Florence, Claire, and Gabby are the best of friends. The trouble is, they are missing Rosie, who tragically died in a car accident. Each of the middle schoolers deals with their grief in very different yet equally profound ways. Gabbie and Florence begin to bicker and lash out at one another, Claire tries to find a new connection with a stranger online, and Millie buries herself in an attempt to figure out the meaning behind a symbol she thinks was connected to Rosie. As time passes, they slowly grow concerned for one another, and along with the help of supportive adults, find ways to redirect their grief in healthier ways.

Although the subject matter is quite serious, this book is written in a way that is very accessible and relatable to kids. Each of the characters is a beautifully illustrated (anthropomorphized) animal that is native to Maryland, where the story is set. The color used in the panels and on the pages makes it easy for readers to transition between the present and the past. 

Grief is an important topic that is rarely dealt with so directly while remaining relatable in modern children’s literature. Dear Rosie is an important book to add to collections, and is highly recommended for libraries that serve students in upper elementary and middle school.

Reviewed by Kristi Favaloro, Skidompha Public Library, Damariscotta

five-stars