The Do-Over

The Do-OverThe Do-Over #1 by Rodrigo Vargas, Coni Yovaniniz
Series: Do-Over #1
Published by Clarion Books on May 23, 2023
ISBN: 035839404X
Pages: 218
Genres: Realistic Fiction
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
three-stars

An appealing middle grade graphic novel centered on friendship and hairstyling. After the death of her mother, Mariana and her father, a hair stylist, move from California to Ohio. Mariana desperately misses her old friends and would love to make new ones, but her anxiety and quiet nature make it hard to approach other kids. There is also a boy who targets Mariana, saying unkind things. When two girls come to the shop of Mariana’s dad to sell their newly-invented hair dye that washes out in three shampoos, Mariana is intrigued. She sees the girls again in school and is determined to introduce herself. When she is finally able to do so, the three become fast friends. Inspired by their hair dye, Mariana proposes that they open their own salon to help people refresh their look through a new hair style.

All of this is a set-up for the heart of the story. With a lot of help from Mariana’s abuela and hard work from the girls, the three do set up a mobile hair salon. They all play a part in the business: one cuts and styles hair, one mixes the dye, and one is the front-end person passing out tea and panetone. There are early successes and then hiccups that threaten the new friendship.

There are some plot points that ask for a suspension of disbelief on the part of the reader: Mariana does not tell her father that she is starting a hair salon despite the fact that his expertise could be useful. Nor does her abuela  tell Mariana’s father about the salon, which seems unlikely since they are close and her abuela is proud of Mariana’s efforts. Mariana’s abuela happens to have an old food truck that she gifts to three middle schoolers to start a mobile hair salon, and those three middle schoolers have enough capital to convert the truck and paint it and have money for panetone and tea and hair dye materials.

On the whole it’s a feel-good story of facing fears, positive personal growth, and relying on community and family support. It is a solid addition to a graphic novel collection where realistic fiction stories about friendship and finding your voice are popular.

Reviewed by Jill O’Connor, Falmouth Middle School

three-stars

Two Tribes

Two TribesTwo Tribes by Emily Bowen Cohen
Published by Heartdrum on August 15, 2023
ISBN: 0062983598
Pages: 245
Genres: Realistic Fiction
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
five-stars

A middle grade graphic novel centered around a girl who is both Jewish and Native and who is struggling to honor both sides of her heritage. Mia lives with her mother and stepfather and they want her to embrace and focus on her Jewish heritage, immersing her in the culture and language of Judaism. But Mia’s estranged father is Muscogee and Mia wants to know more about his side of the family and how Native culture informs who she is, especially since she looks different from all of the other kids at her Jewish day school.

Mia knows that her father lives in Oklahoma with his new family, so she devises a plan to go see him and get much-needed answers about who he is, and therefore who she is. Using her bat mitzvah money and with the help of her best friend covering for her, she takes a bus from California to Oklahoma. Mia does get a window into her indigenous heritage, but she has lied to her mother about where she is and when the truth comes out, Mia has to reckon with her dishonesty. She returns home to California where she must attend Torah study with her rabbi, and while he is helpful in illuminating the impact and weight of her dishonesty, Mia also defends her need for agency and knowledge. The openness of the rabbi and his willingness to learn from Mia at the same time that he is teaching her is refreshing.

The book does a nice job explaining what it’s like to be of two worlds and the ache that comes from not being allowed to ask questions or celebrate a heritage that is important to you. The artwork is clear and engaging. The book is broken into sections separated by single-page drawings and a title like “The Seeds” and “Home on the Range”. The narrative is well-plotted and the conclusion is satisfying showing that when people are open to forgiveness and to change, relationships can be mended. A worthwhile book to put in any school or public library collection.

Reviewed by Jill O’Connor, Falmouth Middle School

five-stars

One in a Million

One in a MillionOne in a Million by Claire Lordon
Published by Candlewick Press on 2023
ISBN: 1536213675
Genres: Biography/Autobiography, Mental Health, Non-Fiction
Format: Graphic Novel, Nonfiction
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars

The subtitle of One in a Million, a graphic memoir by Claire Lordon, is “High school is hard enough without a mysterious illness”, which introduces the reader to Claire’s challenging life. In Claire’s junior year, she begins experiencing excruciating headaches in addition to other symptoms that are difficult to deal with as a teenager such as unexplained weight gain, hair loss, and severe acne. Worse than all of these combined is an extreme lack of concentration and energy, making studying and having the ability to play sports or partake in activities with friends impossible. Claire’s lifeline is her diary and sketchbook. Now an adult, those outlets are the basis for this graphic memoir. One in a Million captures the frustration of feeling ill but not knowing why, the stress of a calendar filled with testing and medical appointments, and the relentless pain and exhaustion that sucks the joy from life. Lordon so clearly channels her teenage self, that the reader cannot help but feel deep empathy with her experience. She drew most of the frames using shapes of purple, with breaks in full black to express negative emotions. Unfortunately the sheer relentless anxiety and depression can overwhelm the reader at times. A trigger warning in the introduction is helpful. Anyone who has ever dealt with a chronic illness or who enjoys medical mysteries would appreciate this graphic memoir.

Reviewed by Melissa M. Orth, Richmond Middle/High School, Richmond, ME

four-stars

Nell of Gumbling

Nell of GumblingNell of Gumbling: My Extremely Normal Fairy-Tale Life by Emma Steinkellner
ISBN: 0593570669
Genres: Fantasy
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars

“Nell of Gumbling: My Extremely Normal Fairy-Tale Life” is a middle grade graphic novel by Emma Steinkellner. The main character, Nell, is a normal seventh grader in the magical city of Gumbling. All seventh graders get assigned an apprenticeship and instead of getting to intern with a famous artist, Nell ends up apprenticing under Mrs. Birdneck, the city archivist. Nell ends up needing to use her archival skills when two adults show up wanting to completely change Gumbling into essentially a theme park.

Written as if we are reading Nell’s journal (complete with her many illustrations), the book alternates between large amounts of text and more standard graphic novel comic style. The illustrations are colorful, bright, and silly. If you pay attention to the details, you’ll find a lot of little jokes that are easily missed. Recommended for ages 8 to 12, this book is a recommended purchase for middle grade graphic novel collections everywhere.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

four-stars

How to Love: A Guide to Feelings & Relationships for Everyone

How to Love: A Guide to Feelings & Relationships for EveryoneHow to Love: A Guide to Feelings & Relationships for Everyone by Alex Norris
ISBN: 1536217883
Genres: Humor
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars
“How to Love” by Alex Norris is a teen/young adult graphic novel all about feelings and relationships. Featuring brightly colored and simple line drawings, Norris brings humor to difficult situations, like dating someone and finding out they are not who you thought they were, or getting in arguments. Some topics may seem a little too simplified, but Norris still manages to convey a deep sincerity, even while making you laugh about it. Some of the topics covered include gender expression, having a crush, friendship, getting dumped, and having arguments in your relationship.

Aimed at ages 14 and up, “How to Love” is a recommended purchase for teen and young adult graphic novel collections.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

four-stars

Two-Headed Chicken: Beak to the Future

Two-Headed Chicken: Beak to the FutureTwo-Headed Chicken: Beak to the Future by Tom Angleberger
Published by Walker Books on 9/12/23
ISBN: 1536223220
Genres: Humor, Science Fiction
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars
The two-headed chicken is back in this entertaining graphic novel sequel.  In this adventure, the two-headed chicken experiences time travel as they search for their missing Astrocap, which allows them to jump from universe to universe.   In their quest, they travel to random points in time and encounter a hungry dinosaur, face an angry moose, and meet poet Emily Dickinson.  The chaotic plot is fast-paced with many unexpected twists and turns.  There is some type of humor on every page and kids will no doubt laugh out loud.  One thing that distinguishes this graphic novel from others are the interactive activities readers find along the way, like funny quizzes, a maze, and spot the difference (between two pages).  Elementary school readers who appreciate humor and randomness will love this graphic novel.  

Reviewed by Lindsay Varnum, Orono Public Library

four-stars

Hoops

HoopsHoops: A Graphic Novel by Matt Tavares
Published by Candlewick Press on March 14, 2023
ISBN: 1536201367
Genres: Historical Fiction, Sports
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars
Hoops is a graphic novel inspired by the true story of the first women’s high school varsity basketball team in a town in Indiana.  The girls on this team love to play basketball, but are forced to overcome many obstacles on their path to the playoffs, obstacles the boys’ team doesn’t have to deal with.  The girls refuse to be quiet about the inequities and find different ways to fight for what they need.  This graphic novel is perfect for upper elementary students.  It revolves around the basketball team and their amazing first season, but it also offers a glimpse into life for women in the 1970s and includes elements of friendship and some romance.  The pace of this graphic novel is pretty quick and there is a great balance between text heavy panels and pages and panels and pages that are solely illustrations.  This would be great for any school or public library collection.

Reviewed by Lindsay Varnum, Orono Public Library

four-stars

The Alchemyst – The Graphic Novel

The Alchemyst – The Graphic NovelThe Alchemyst: The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel Graphic Novel by Chris Chalik, Michael Scott
ISBN: 0593304675
Genres: Fantasy
Format: Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
two-stars
The new graphic novel version of “The Alchemyst – The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel” by Michael Scott is adapted by Nicole Andelfinger and illustrated by Chris Chalik. Twins Sophie and Josh discover that magic is real and that Josh’s bookseller boss is actually the immortal Nicholas Flamel. When a magical book is stolen, the twins must face danger to get it back and save the world. This adaptation of the bestselling young adult fiction series may satisfy fans of the original. The storyline is very close to the original book. Artwork seems a bit stilted and some of the word bubble lettering is very tough to read, but the plot is engaging. Written for ages 12-14, this book is recommended for large YA graphic novel collections where fantasy is popular.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

two-stars

Pizza y Taco: ¿Quién es el mejor?

Pizza y Taco: ¿Quién es el mejor?Pizza y Taco: ¿Quién es el mejor?: (A Graphic Novel) (Pizza and Taco) (Spanish Edition) by Stephen Shaskan
ISBN: 0593704320
Genres: Humor
Format: Early Reader, Graphic Novel
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
four-stars

“Pizza y Taco: ¿Quién es el mejor?” is the Spanish edition of “Pizza and Taco: Who’s the best?” by Stephen Shaskan. Pizza and Taco are best friends, but which one of them is the best? They vote on it, but end up in a tie (or with a write-in candidate winning their second voting attempt). They decide to have a competition! Who is the best? Bright and engaging illustrations that are a combination of photos and cartoony drawing catch the eye. Written for ages 5 through 8, this is a silly graphic novel about friendship with lots of goofy antics, this book is a must-buy for all youth graphic novel collections.

Reviewed by Kate Radke, Walker Memorial Library, Westbrook, ME.

four-stars

All the Lovely Bad Ones: A Ghost Story Graphic Novel

All the Lovely Bad Ones: A Ghost Story Graphic NovelAll the Lovely Bad Ones Graphic Novel: A Ghost Story Graphic Novel by Mary Downing Hahn, Naomi Franquiz, Joamette Gil, Brittany Peer, Scott Peterson
Published by Clarion Books on August 29, 2023
ISBN: 0358650143
Pages: 160
Genres: Horror, Supernatural
Format: Graphic Novel
Goodreads
four-stars

Graphic Novel adaptation of Hahn’s horror story. When Travis and his sister Corey land themselves in a little too much trouble and are disinvited from their summer camp, their parents send them to Vermont to spend the summer with their grandmother. Their grandmother has recently purchased an old Inn but is worried that business is down. The Inn has a reputation as being haunted but tourists aren’t coming because there have been no alleged ghost sightings in years. Travis and Corey hatch a plan to fake ghost sightings to increase business. It works for awhile – business picks up and ghost hunters start visiting – but their grandmother is increasingly unhappy. When Travis and Corey’s antics wake up the real ghosts, things go from bad to worse. Travis and Corey learn the history of the Inn – it served as a poor house and was run by an evil brother and sister. The sister may be one of the ghosts they’ve awakened and her depiction by the artists is especially scary. This horror story is the perfect level of creepy and scary for upper elementary and middle grade readers.

Reviewed by Karen Sandlin Silverman, Mt. Ararat Middle School, Topsham

four-stars