What Makes Us by Rafi Mittlefehldt
Published by Candlewick Press on October 15, 2019
ISBN: 0763697508
Pages: 352
Genres: Realistic Fiction
Format: Chapter Book Fiction
Goodreads

This incredibly heavy book attempts to tackle many topics and themes, some of which are parent/child relationships, prejudice, violence in protest, and terrorism.  Unfortunately, the overall message of the book gets lost in too many plot points and viewpoints from three different main characters.  First is Eran who has grown up with only his very stoic and private mother.  His mother formerly known as Devorah.  And Eran’s new friend Jade who knows her parents are keeping something from her.  The main storyline features Eran’s passion about social justice and protest plan that goes wrong.  He ends up in a shoving match with another person caught on camera.  The press then digs into his past and discovers the truth about Eran’s father and his family.  Devorah’s storyline is told via flashbacks to Eran’s childhood and the fallout from what his father did.  Intertwined with this is Jade’s storyline of being on the fringe of Eran’s life and struggling with whatever secret her family is keeping from her.  Her’s is the storyline that really over-complicates.   There’s a lot to relate to the current climate, with unjust hatred and racism being lobbied at innocent parties simply because their background is another religion or country.  Mittlefehldt’s second book falls short of its goals by including too much.  It may still be of interest to teens studying the current political climate or talking about peaceful vs violent protest.  Best for grades 8+.

Reviewed by Kara Reiman, Maine State Library