Middle Grade Fiction – MSL Book Review

Safiyyah’s War by Hiba Noor Khan
Published by Andersen Press on July 6, 2023
ISBN: 1839133139
Pages: 336
Genres: Historical Fiction
Format: Middle Grade Fiction
Goodreads
five-stars

During WWII, the brave leaders at the Grand Mosque of Paris protected Jewish people with forged religious documents and risked their lives transporting over a thousand Jewish people to safety using catacombs under the mosque. Though there are countless options when it comes to stories about this time period, this history has been largely forgotten and Hiba Noor Khan is hoping to change that with her debut novel, Safiyyah’s War.

Safiyyah is an adventurous, spirited, and thoughtful young Muslim girl living above the mosque when Nazis invade Paris. It is clear throughout the novel that war is not a children’s game, but without many options Safiyyah’s family cautiously allows her to aid the Resistance movement. Khan’s prose is often poetic, but doesn’t shy away from intensely emotional moments. Families are separated, people are hungry, and Safiyyah herself survives the initial bombing of Paris. Despite the horrific circumstances, Safiyyah never stops fighting and side plots about kittens, plants, libraries, and religion offer respite for the characters and readers. This story’s honest depiction of children traumatized by war and the realities of life under occupation may be difficult for sensitive readers, but the overall message of perseverance, bravery, love, and hope will resonate with readers drawn to strong female leads and novels about war.

Safiyyah’s War has the perfect combination of forgotten history, dynamic characters, and beautiful prose that make it a fresh classic in an oversaturated genre. Nominated for Cream of the Crop.

Reviewed by Ivy Burns, Merrill Memorial Library, Yarmouth

The Wrong Way Home by Kate O'Shaughnessy
on April 2, 2024
ISBN: 0593650735
Genres: Realistic Fiction
Format: Middle Grade Fiction
Source: MSL Book Review
Goodreads
five-stars

When Fern’s mother wakes her in the night and whisks her away from the only home she remembers, Fern becomes angry. For the past six years, she has lived on The Ranch – a “sustainable futurist community.” Fern enjoys the hard work and the mission of the leader of The Ranch, Dr. Ben, has instilled in its inhabitants. They are working toward surviving war and global warming. What young Fern does not realize is that The Ranch is a cult. Fern wishes to return and starts a plan on how to do so. Yet, life outside does have its perks. She comes to enjoy having a say in her life, making her own decisions, and making friends.

While a book about a twelve year old who is a member of a cult makes red flags fly, the novel is exceptionally well written and handles this often trauma inducing topic in a way that is perfect for middle grade readers.

Reviewed by Heidi Kopishke, Camden Hills Regional High School, Rockport, ME.