Cake Vs. Pie is, at first glance, a book that might appeal to our collective love of desserts, as well as our cultural fascination with competition. While the illustrations are quite colorful and charming, with anthropomorphized treats displaying an array of emotions, the storyline itself might not be what most parents and teachers are hoping to share with children.

Cake is used to being everyone’s favorite. With a very heavy use of puns, Bardhan-Quallen leads readers through the community of desserts, and it quickly becomes apparent that Cake is much-beloved. When Pie moves to the neighborhood, other characters begin to adore the newcomer. While the two are initially friends, jealousy quickly flares, and their interactions take on an uncomfortable ‘frenemies’ quality. They literally end up in a boxing ring and battle over who is better. Readers may hope for a satisfying end with a lesson about healthy friendships, but that never quite happens. Cake takes some responsibility for the mess, but Pie never does, and the situation is glossed over by them cleaning up and declaring their friendship. The book ends with an image of a hot dog and burger about to fight in the ring, surrounded by a crowd of upset food items.

This picture book is listed as being recommended for ages 4-8.

Reviewed by Kristi Favaloro, Skidompha Public Library, Damariscotta