The Cookie Vote

Authors: Margaret McNamara & Daniel Bernstrom

This picture book for ages 4-8 is the latest in the Mr. Tiffin’s Classroom series. Mr. Tiffin, whose students are learning how bills become laws, announces that the student who comes up with the best idea will have the opportunity to present his or her bill to Representative Noor during their upcoming class trip to the state capitol. Jeremy believes his state needs an official cookie, but his classmates begin to argue over which cookie flavor is the best. As is appropriate for a civics lesson, the class settles the debate with a vote. When the students visit the State House to present their bill, Jeremy learns that every vote counts and that compromise is often a necessary, albeit a frustrating part of government. The end of the book highlights three real student-sponsored bills which led to the appointment of three official state cookies. Additionally, a recipe for Jeremy’s official state cookie is also included. This book would be a nice supplement to a school lesson on government, and may even inspire students to draft their own bills.

3 stars

Reviewed by Lindsey Hopkins, Jay-Niles Memorial Library, Jay